DTSC DrillTechSOLIDS CONTROL · DWM← Main site
Technical Library · Lost Circulation

Lost Circulation Center

Practical guidance on diagnosing mud losses, selecting LCM, and understanding the relationship between lost circulation, drilling fluids, and solids-control systems.

The hook

Lost circulation is not only a drilling problem. Poor solids-control decisions can increase mud losses, waste valuable LCM, and significantly raise well costs. This center looks at losses from the angle SC DrillTech knows best — the surface system.

1What is lost circulation?

Lost circulation is the loss of whole drilling fluid from the wellbore into the formation — fluid leaving through fractures, vugs or permeable rock, not filtering through a cake. It is measured by what the pits lose, in barrels per hour.

Losses vs fluid loss — don’t confuse them. Fluid loss (API filtrate) is the small, controlled seepage of liquid through the filter cake, measured in mL. Lost circulation is whole mud — solids and all — disappearing into the formation. One is a cake-quality number; the other is a returns problem.

Operational impact: lost hydrostatic head (well-control risk), lost expensive fluid, non-productive time, and in severe cases an inability to keep the hole full. It is one of the costliest events on a well.

2Types of lost circulation

Losses are graded by rate, because the rate decides the response:

TypeTypical rateSymptom & impact
Seepage< ~10 bbl/hrSlow pit drop; often permeability or near-balance — manage with fine LCM/sweeps.
Partial~10–50 bbl/hrClear, steady pit loss with returns still at surface — LCM pills, monitor ECD.
Severe> ~50 bbl/hrHeavy loss, reduced returns — coarse LCM, pills, slow the pumps.
TotalNo returnsNo fluid back at surface — hole may not stay full; well-control priority.

The grade is the first thing a field diagnosis establishes — it sets both the urgency and the LCM strategy.

3Common causes

Where the fluid goes tells you what you are fighting:

  • Natural fractures — pre-existing open fractures that take fluid as soon as they’re intersected.
  • Induced fractures — the well breaks the rock itself when ECD exceeds the fracture gradient. This is the one solids control influences most directly.
  • Cavernous / vugular formations — karst, caverns and large voids that can take total losses instantly.
  • Highly permeable zones — coarse sands and gravels that drink fluid through pore space (seepage to partial).
  • Weak / depleted formations — low fracture resistance, easily induced once pressure creeps up.

Note the pattern: two of these — induced fractures and weak formations — are pressure-driven, and pressure is driven by ECD, which is driven by the fine-solids load. That is the SC DrillTech angle.

4Field diagnosis guide

You rarely see the loss zone — you read it from surface signs. Four signals, read together, grade the loss:

SignalWhat it shows
Pit volume trendThe primary measure — rate and shape of the active-pit drop = the loss rate.
Flow show (flowline)Returns reduced vs none = partial vs total; the flow-out paddle confirms.
Standpipe pressureA drop can signal losses (and U-tube); rising ECD before a loss is the warning.
Mud propertiesClimbing PV/ECD ahead of an event points to a fine-solids cause, not just the formation.

Read all four. A pit drop with full flowline returns and a falling SPP reads differently from a total loss with no returns — and the mud trend tells you whether you helped cause it at surface.

5Lost circulation & solids control

This is where SC DrillTech has something few others say. The solids-control system can either protect you from losses — or quietly make them worse and waste the LCM you’re paying for.

The lost-circulation chain: poor solids control at surface raises PV, ECD and pressure until ECD exceeds fracture resistance and losses occur
The surface-to-loss-zone chain. Better solids control breaks it at step one — lower ECD, lower loss risk.

LCM & shale shakers

The shaker is where LCM is won or lost. Run normal screens during an LCM treatment and the deck screens out the very material you just pumped — throwing expensive fibres and flakes straight to waste. The fix is deliberate screen selection: coarsen the deck, or bypass the shaker for the LCM circulation so the material survives to the active system. See the shaker guide and screen blinding.

LCM & mud cleaners

The mud cleaner’s fine screen will also reject coarse LCM. During treatment, know when to bypass the cones / cleaner so the LCM isn’t classified out — then return to normal once the pill is placed. It’s an operational decision, not a set-and-forget. See the mud cleaner guide.

LCM & centrifuges

A centrifuge running through an LCM treatment can strip out the sized material you need in suspension, and load itself with fibrous solids it was never meant to handle. The recommendation: idle or isolate the centrifuge during active LCM work, and resume once the treatment has done its job. See the centrifuge guide.

LCM recovery & reducing unnecessary losses

Beyond protecting the pill, the bigger prize is not generating the problem: controlling ultra-fine drilled solids keeps PV and ECD down so you induce fewer losses in the first place. Better solids control upstream means fewer LCM events downstream.

Common solids-control mistakes during a loss event

  • Leaving fine screens on the shaker — screening out the LCM you just bought.
  • Running the centrifuge through the treatment — removing sized material from suspension.
  • Forgetting to bypass the cones / mud cleaner during the pill.
  • Letting LGS and PV climb unchecked — raising ECD until the formation breaks.
  • Not restoring normal solids control after the pill — leaving the system half-configured.

6LCM categories

LCM is grouped by particle shape, because shape decides how it bridges and seals. An overview — sizing and selection are an expanding topic here:

CategoryPurposeTypical application
FibrousSpan and mat across openingsSeepage to partial; builds a base for other LCM
FlakyLay over and cover the facePermeable zones and fractures; surface sealing
GranularBridge and plug at the throatWider fractures; the structural bridging particle

Effective pills often blend all three — granular to bridge, fibrous to span, flaky to seal. Detailed selection and sizing are flagged below as coming soon.

7Economic impact

Losses are expensive on more than the fluid line. A single event compounds across the cost sheet:

  • Lost mud — every barrel into the formation is barrels of base fluid and chemicals gone.
  • Extra dilution & build — rebuilding lost volume, often the most expensive lever.
  • Extra waste — more volume to treat and haul, especially on NAF.
  • Logistics — LCM, barite and base-fluid resupply, sometimes by boat or air.
  • Rig time — NPT chasing the loss is usually the biggest number of all.

Simple example: a partial loss of 30 bbl/hr on an OBM at a fully-loaded cost of a few hundred dollars a barrel runs into five figures a day before a single hour of NPT — which is why prevention at surface (controlling ECD via solids) pays for the whole solids-control effort many times over.

8Future expansion

Coming soon · expanding

Where this center is growing

Version 1 establishes the topic from the solids-control and drilling-fluids angle. Planned next:

LCM Selection GuideLCM Sizing CalculatorLost Circulation Case StudiesWellbore StrengtheningAdvanced Lost Circulation Engineering

?FAQ

Is lost circulation a solids-control problem?
Not always — but more often than people credit. Natural fractures and caverns are pure formation events, yet induced fractures and weak-zone losses are pressure-driven, and the fine-solids load raises ECD that helps break the formation. Poor solids control also wastes the LCM you pump. So solids control both helps prevent losses and protects the cure.
Why does the shaker waste LCM?
A normal shaker screen rejects coarse LCM the same way it rejects cuttings — it screens your fibres and flakes to waste. During a treatment you coarsen the screens or bypass the shaker so the LCM survives to the active system, then restore normal screening afterward.
Should I run the centrifuge during an LCM treatment?
Generally no. A centrifuge can strip the sized LCM out of suspension and load itself with fibrous material it isn’t designed for. The usual recommendation is to idle or isolate it during active LCM work and resume once the pill has done its job.
What’s the difference between lost circulation and fluid loss?
Fluid loss (API filtrate) is small, controlled liquid seepage through the filter cake, measured in millilitres. Lost circulation is whole mud — solids and all — leaving into the formation, measured in barrels per hour. Different problems, different cures.
Next step

Losing returns and chasing it downhole?

Before the next LCM pill, let SC DrillTech check whether your fines load is feeding the problem — a remote review of your PV/ECD trend, PSD and solids-control performance.

Put these numbers to work on your rig

Send your shift data — we read it against API RP 13C and tell you exactly what to change.

Request a remote evaluation →